“The first and most obvious reason for believing that Elihu was in the right about what he said is that he did not get rebuked by God. In Chapter 42 verses 7 and 8, Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar are told that they did not speak to God as was right. In Chapter 38 Verse 2 God basically tells Job that he has been speaking in foolish ignorance. We know that this was addressed to Job and not Elihu because in 42:3, Job quotes and responds to that accusation directly. Job is also rebuked in 40:8 for defending his own righteousness above God’s. The only man in the conversation who is mysteriously missing from God’s reproof is Elihu.
There are only three possible reasons for his absence:
1. Elihu said nothing that deserved critique.
2. Elihu wasn’t there, which we have already discussed in the last chapter. Even if God commanded Moses to add him to the record, if Elihu had been rebuked, Moses would have made that adjustment too.
3. Elihu was so incredibly wrong and insignificant that God simply decided he wasn’t worth scolding.
Since we’ve already spoken about the second one, let’s discuss that third possibility. If Elihu was unworthy of notice or mention by God, would his speeches even be in the Bible? God’s word is inspired and every part of it is useful (2 Tim. 3:16-17). If that’s the case, Elihu’s speeches have to be useful for something. If their only use is a final temptation for Job, then God would have given Job a chance to respond before making His entrance. They’re not much good as a temptation and final test from Satan if there is no opportunity to act on it.
So then, could it be that they’re only there to show the reader how not to respond or speak in circumstances such as these? This would be the same concept as one reason for including the Pharisees’ accusation that Jesus cast out demons by Beelzebul. The first problem with that idea is that Jesus did rebuke the Pharisees. The second problem is that, on occasions like that in Scripture, the context that God has written around the incident makes it clear that this person was speaking falsely. God most definitely did not make that clear about Elihu’s words if the endless controversies about him and his role are anything to go by. That’s not all, though. There is another problem with this interpretation besides the fact that it makes Elihu’s speeches largely useless.
The belief that God would have ignored Elihu is inconsistent with His character of justice, fatherly discipline, and mercy. If Elihu spoke so incorrectly, then he needed rebuke and correction more than the three friends did. After all, Elihu claimed to have perfect knowledge and to have received it from God (Job 36:3-4); the friends were not so presumptuous.
Based on that, God’s judgement on Elihu should have been even more severe if he was lying or wrong. It also should have been on the same occasion as the three friends in order to vindicate Job and clarify with all five of these men where their folly lay. It is unlikely that God would have chosen to wait until later or the afterlife to address this with Elihu when He chose to reprove the friends then and there.
However, even if He had waited, that would mean that not only did God leave Elihu out of the discipline and opportunity to learn, but also that He left Elihu out of Job’s intercessory prayer for forgiveness on behalf of those who had attacked him. So then, Elihu isn’t told that he did wrong, isn’t given a chance to repent and be forgiven, and is treated as though he doesn’t exist? That doesn’t sound like God (Heb. 12:6, 2 Pet. 3:9, Jer. 32:19 etc.).
To me, the only logical explanation for the fact that God did not rebuke Elihu is that Elihu did nothing to deserve rebuke. This, however, is not the only evidence we have that Elihu was a prophet and an authoritative voice in the Book of Job.”